23 Best Shows Like Lucifer | Unveil The Mystery Of Supernatural Cops Today!


Mystery is a distinct genre that generates a lot of curiosity; that’s why many people are fond of them. Therefore, I have brought some mesmerizing shows like Lucifer known for their complex mystery formula!

Lucifer (2016-2021) centers on Lucifer, who lands on earth after developing disinterest in his throne. After landing, he leads a hedonistic lifestyle but ends up helping a homicide detective in solving a murder case. Amidst all this, Lucifer starts wondering whether he belongs to this planet and what’s the mystery behind a supernatural force that is disturbing him. Learn more about such mysteries through shows like Lucifer on Netflix!

Why wander a lot when the catalog of Netflix has a significant amount of shows like Lucifer? Steam them without any delay! 

23 Shows Like Lucifer On Netflix | Unbox The Plots That You Haven’t Till Now!

23 Best Shows Like Lucifer | Unveil The Mystery Of Supernatural Cops Today!

When it comes to noting down a worthy mysterious series, Lucifer ranks on top. If you search for shows that can give you Lucifer vibes, here is a bunch of shows like Lucifer prepared for you!

Why does my cat chew on me? 6 Reaso...
Why does my cat chew on me? 6 Reason you should know .

Genre: Mystery

Rotten Tomatoes: 88%

Cast: Lauren German, Tom Ellis

Watch it on: Netflix

Running Time: 42m 

Also, Read | 35+ Teen Drama Shows Like Gossip Girl That Will Make You Relive Your Teens! 

1# Evil (2019-Present) | There Is A Reason Behind Every Activity

23 Best Shows Like Lucifer | Unveil The Mystery Of Supernatural Cops Today!

If you have experienced something supernatural, you’ll surely be able to connect chords with Evil! At the core of the story, there is a psychologist who is assisted by a priest, David. Interestingly, both of them never fail by the wayside in investigating activities in a church. But this time! Something will not allow them to leap to a conclusion easily! Check out what it is!

The series was praised by critics for its smartly-written plotline. Besides this, the series allows the viewer to dwell in the depth of the questions that the plotline brings forth. Due to all this, the series received the Critic’s Choice Super Awards.

Release Date: September 26, 2019

IMDb: 7.7

Rotten Tomatoes: 93%

Genre: Drama, Mystery

Cast: Mike Colter, Katja Herbers

Watch it on: Paramount Plus

Running Time: 40m 

2# Supernatural (2005-2020) | A Tale Of Two Distinct Brothers

23 Best Shows Like Lucifer | Unveil The Mystery Of Supernatural Cops Today!

Supernatural narrates the story of two brothers who know how to tackle demons and supernatural powers. Besides this, they can hunt for them and detain them. As a result, they gained mastery over having control over supernatural powers. And the source that made them skilled in this was their father. For how long their lives will remain unaffected by their professions. Are splashes of supernatural powers bound to fall on their lives?

You’ll be surprised to know that the series has witnessed many spin-offs since its release. And all of them are worth watching. Besides, critics gave the series favorable reviews with praise for the plotline. So, when are you planning to stream it?

Release Date: September 13, 2005

IMDb: 8.5

Rotten Tomatoes: 93%

Genre: Mystery

Cast: 38m 

Watch it on: Amazon Prime Video 

Running Time: 47m 

3# Forever (2014-2015) | Unlock The Key To Immortality

23 Best Shows Like Lucifer | Unveil The Mystery Of Supernatural Cops Today!

Can you believe that humans can live for 200 years? Wake up. It’s not a joke! Dr. Henry Morgan in Forever has been alive for the past 200 years. Although he is a medical examiner, who works with a detective, he has failed to get to the root of his immortality. But he is just on the way to uncovering the mystery. What could be the possible reason behind this? A curse or a blessing?

Though critics welcomed the series with mixed reviews, after conducting various online polls, the series was voted one of the best television series. Also, it took only a few days for the series to gain high viewership.

Release Date: September 22, 2014

IMDb: 8.2 

Rotten Tomatoes: 54%

Genre: Drama, Mystery 

Cast: Alana de la Garza, Ion Gruffudd

Watch it on: Amazon Instant Video 

Running Time: 45m 

Also, Read | 26 Inquisitive Shows Like White Collar | Shows That Are A Pool Of Mysteries!

4# Constantine (2014-2015) | Ability To Deal With Demons

23 Best Shows Like Lucifer | Unveil The Mystery Of Supernatural Cops Today!

Constantine sheds light on the life of a demon hunter, John, who no longer feels the need to fight demons because his soul belongs to another world. But the tables turn when the daughter of his friend, Liv, becomes the target of demons. Surprisingly, she has the power to predict supernatural activities, which is a threat to upcoming demons. As a result, Liv and John associate to battle against the demons and send them back to hell. Will both of them succeed in this?

If you know about DC comic characters, you can easily recognize the lead character of this one of the amazing shows like Lucifer. Interestingly, you can enjoy more of this series through its spin-off, Constantine: City Of Demons (2018-2019).

Release Date: October 24, 2014

IMDb: 7.5

Rotten Tomatoes: 72%

Genre: Horror, Drama 

Cast: Angelica Celaya, Matt Ryan 

Watch it on: Amazon Prime Video 

Running Time: 43m 

5# Good Omens (2019-Present) | An Unheard Duo

23 Best Shows Like Lucifer | Unveil The Mystery Of Supernatural Cops Today!

Good Omens portrays the life of a fussy angel and a loose-living demon, who are highly fascinated by life on earth. As a result, both partner and harp on how they can stop a monstrous demon from approaching the earth. Interestingly, the demon has opted for a disguised identity. How will the angel and demon be able to save the earth? 

Many fans loved the partnership of the demon and angel, which is relatively fresh compared to other supernatural movies. Also, the series was nominated for awards like the Golden Tailor Awards and Saturn Awards

Release Date: May 31, 2019

IMDb: 8

Rotten Tomatoes: 84%

Genre: Fantasy, Mystery

Cast: David Tennant, Michael Sheen 

Watch it on: Amazon Prime Video 

Running Time: 51m 

6# Moonlight (2007-2008) | A Tale Of A Vampire

23 Best Shows Like Lucifer | Unveil The Mystery Of Supernatural Cops Today!

If you are fond of vampire stories, you’ll not hesitate to give a green signal to Moonlight! The core of the plot deals with a vampire, who is an investigator as well. Because he had tasted defeat 60 years back, he is seeking to take revenge. On the contrary, he falls in love with a human which might be another challenge! Let’s see how he will be able to achieve his goals!

The series ranked well on various surveys and became a critically acclaimed series. Also, it became one of the most-watched series in 2007.

Release Date: September 28, 2007

IMDb: 7.6

Rotten Tomatoes: 22%

Genre: Drama, Mystery

Cast: Jason Dohring, Jordan Belfi

Watch it on: Vudu

Running Time: 42m 

Also, Read | 9 Bewitching Shows Like Suits On Netflix | Keep Trying Your Luck!

7# Sleepy Hollow (2013-2017) | Travel Back To Solve Mysteries

23 Best Shows Like Lucifer | Unveil The Mystery Of Supernatural Cops Today!

Sleepy Hollow is all about Ichabod Crane, who is transcended a few years back to unbox an ancient mystery. On the contrary, he is on a mission to stop a headless horseman to stop killing people. How is this puzzle going to get solved?

Watching the series is highly enjoyable because of its exciting action scenes. Though the plotline seems scary, you’ll find it less horrifying and more mysterious. 

Release Date: September 16, 2013

IMDb: 7.3

Rotten Tomatoes: 76%

Genre: Drama, Mystery

Cast: Nicole Beharie, Tom Mison

Watch it on: Hulu 

Running Time: 41m 

8# Angel (1999-2004) | A Fresh Start Of A Vampire 

23 Best Shows Like Lucifer | Unveil The Mystery Of Supernatural Cops Today!

Angels bring in the picture of a vampire angel who decides to start fresh in Los Angeles after losing his true love. Rather than starting fresh, he indulges with a group of new friends who are all set to upsurge the darker side of the vampire angel. Besides them, the vampire angel gets acquainted with several other demons. Where will his journey take him to?

This interesting show in the list of shows like Lucifer is a spin-off of Buffy The Vampire Slayer (1997). Interestingly, the genesis of the lead character is a movie of the same name that appeared in 1996. 

Release Date: October 5, 1999

IMDb: 7.9 

Rotten Tomatoes: 76%

Genre: Drama 

Cast: Charisma Carpenter, David Boreanaz

Watch it on: Hulu 

Running Time: 41m 

Also, Read | 18 Heart Warming Shows Like Virgin River On Netflix That Will Leave You Wanting For More! 

More Shows Like Lucifer On Netflix | Get The Best Of Supernatural Shows! 

23 Best Shows Like Lucifer | Unveil The Mystery Of Supernatural Cops Today!

Besides Lucifer, here is an elongated list of shows like Lucifer that will dwell you in their mysterious plots. Have a look at all of them!

Show’s NameDirectorIMDb OverviewWhere To watch
The Vampire Diaries (2009-2017)Chris Grismer7.7 Amazon Prime Video
Fringe (2008-2013)J.J Abrams8.5 Amazon Prime Video
American Gods (2017)Ian McShane7.7Amazon Prime Video
Preacher (2016-2019)Rogen7.9Amazon Prime Video
Pushing Daisies (2007-2009)Lawrence Trilling8.4HBO Max
Chilling Adventures Of Sabrina (2018)Alex Pillai7.4Netflix 
Castle (2009-2016)Jonathan Frakes 8.1Hulu Plus
Grimm (2011-2017)David Giutoli7.8Amazon Prime Video
Limitless (2015-2016)Marc Webb7.7Paramount Plus
The Dresden Files (2007)Michael Nankin7.6Amazon Instant Video
Reaper (2007-2009)Thomas Schnauz7.8Amazon Prime Video
Lost Girl (2010-2016)Ron Murphy7.6Vudu
iZombie (2015-2019)Rose Mclver7.8Netflix
Arrow (2012)David Ramsey7.5Netflix
Blood Ties (2017)David Winning 7.2Netflix

Final Words 

These were all the shows like Lucifer that you can consider for your primetime. Therefore, it’s time to set up your room and stream these shows that are packed with intense mysteries. Share the one whom you would like to give a thumbs up!

Shraddha Singh
Shraddha Singh
Shraddha is an English literature student who is passionate about playing with words. She is a reserved person who speaks out through her writing. Her writings are usually inspired by whatever she feels in her surroundings. She aims to bring more people into reading and writing because it’s an easy way to communicate with a larger segment of people. Besides writing for others, she writes for herself in poems and write-ups. Though she has just started her career in writing, she wishes to get deep into it.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here