25+ Thrilling Shows Like The Sinner | Come And Solve These Murders Mysteries! 


Do you also find murder mysteries morbidly fascinating? Do you have a passion for solving gruesome murders? I understand if you do because I like anything remotely related to cold-blooded murders too! And that’s why I have made a list of shows like The Sinner (2017) to give you more murder mysteries to solve!

The Sinner is an American crime drama series based on a 1999 novel by Petra Hammesfahr, The Sinner. It follows a police detective as he investigates the crimes committed by unlikely culprits and tries to understand their motives behind the crime. If you find the police procedural for solving murders intriguing, you will surely like other shows like The Sinner. Watch these shows now!

25+ Shows Like The Sinner That Will Make You A Detective Too! 

Each season take a look at a new case. For example, the first season looked into the past of a troubled woman and uncovered her motives for stabbing a man to death. The final and fourth season follows Harry Ambrose on vacation, trying to recover from his previous case. But a new tragedy strikes, and he has to help his team with a further investigation. 

Now, if that description awakened the inner nosy Sherlock Holmes in you, and you too would like to solve a case or two, some shows like The Sinner will help you in your heroic deed!  

  • Release Date: August 2, 2017
  • Running Time: 40-54 minutes
  • Cast: Bill Pullman, Jessica Biel, Christopher Abbott, Dohn Norwood, Abbey Miller. 
  • IMDb Rating: 7.9/10
  • Where to Watch: Netflix, Fubo TV, Google Play, Amazon Instant Video. 

1# Seven Seconds (2018)

20 Thrilling Shows Like The Sinner | Come And Solve These Murders Mysteries!  

The American crime drama, Seven Seconds (2018) is based on the movie The Major by Yuri Bykov. Seven Seconds follows the story of Brenton Butler’s death. Brenton Butler is a 15-year-old black cyclist who dies when a white Newark Police Department cop, Peter Jablonski, accidentally hits him with his car. He calls his fellow corrupt officers to the scene to cover up the accident.

However, the city quickly explodes with racial tensions due to injustice. And the longer the case drags without action, the tenser the situation becomes in the northeastern town.

  • Release Date: February 23, 2018
  • Running Time: 54-80 minutes
  • Cast: Regina King, Russell Hornsby, Zackary Momoh, David Lyons, Beau Knapp, Raul Castillo.
  • IMDb Rating: 7.7/10
  • Where to Watch: Netflix, Prime Video, Hulu.

2# The Outsider (2020)

20 Thrilling Shows Like The Sinner | Come And Solve These Murders Mysteries!  

The Outsider (2020)  is a Psychological horror crime show based on Stephen King’s novel, The Outsider. This show is a must-watch if you love Stephen King and his work. The Outsider follows investigators as they probe into the gruesome murder of a young boy. The boy was discovered with saliva and human bite marks on his body. The coach of the team he was a part of was arrested on suspicion.

But the investigators soon realized they were dealing with a supernatural force. The revelation leads them to question everything they believe in.

  • Release Date: January 12, 2020
  • Running Time: 50-60 minutes
  • Cast: Ben Mendelsohn, Bill Camp, Jeremy Bobb, Mare Winningham, Paddy Considine.
  • IMDb Rating: 7.7/10
  • Where to Watch: Amazon Instant Video, iTunes, Google Play, Netflix.

3# Black Spot (2017)

20 Thrilling Shows Like The Sinner | Come And Solve These Murders Mysteries!  

Black Spot (2017) is a French-Belgian crime drama thriller series that follows Police Major Laurène Weiss as she investigates the murders in her hometown Villefranche. Villefranche is a small, isolated fictional town surrounded by a large forest where most of the murders take place.

A new eccentric prosecutor, Franck Siriani, arrives in Villefranche to understand why the town’s crime rate is six times higher than the national average. The prosecutor is also interested in learning the truths of the Major’s murky past. Will the Major be able to stop the supernatural phenomena before the number of inhabitants of the small town dwindles further?

  • Release Date: April 10, 2017.
  • Running Time: 52 minutes
  • Cast: Suliane Brahim, Hubert Delattre, Laurent Capelluto
  • IMDb Rating: 7.4/10
  • Where to Watch: Netflix, Prime Video

4# Mindhunter (2017-2019)

25+ Thrilling Shows Like The Sinner | Come And Solve These Murders Mysteries! 

Mindhunter (2017) is a Psychological thriller television series based on a 1995 true-crime book by John E. Douglas and Mark Olshaker, Mindhunter: Inside the FBI’s Elite Serial Crime Unit.

Mindhunter revolves around FBI agents Holden Ford and Bill Tench, who, along with psychologist Wendy Carr investigate imprisoned serial killers as a part of their research project. They do this to discover the crime’s psychology and apply the knowledge to ongoing cases. The show features many notable serial killers like Montie Rissell, Jerry Brudos, and Richard Speck.

  • Release Date: October 13, 2017
  • Running Time: 34-73 minutes
  • Cast: Jonathan Groff, Holt McCallany, Hannah Gross, Cotter Smith, Anna Torv
  • IMDb Rating: 8.6/10
  • Where to Watch: Netflix, Prime Video

5# Marcella (2016-present)

20 Thrilling Shows Like The Sinner | Come And Solve These Murders Mysteries!  

Marcella (2016) is a British Nordic noir detective series that follows the story of former London detective Marcella Backland. The detective decides to return to work after an 11-year-long break upon discovering that a serial killer is active again.

Adding to her troubles, Marcella has to deal with a troublesome personal life. Her husband of fifteen years is leaving her for another woman. Also, Marcella suffers from Dissociative Identity Disorder and has violent blackouts. Things become even more twisted when her husband’s lover is found murdered, and she begins suspecting her role in the crime.

  • Release Date: April 4, 2016.
  • Running Time: 50-60 minutes
  • Cast: Anna Friel, Nicholas Pinnock, Ray Panthaki, Jamie Bamber, Jack Doolan
  • IMDb Rating: 7.4/10
  • Where to Watch: Netflix, Prime Video

6# The Alienist (2018-2020)

20 Thrilling Shows Like The Sinner | Come And Solve These Murders Mysteries!  

The Alienist (2018) is an American Period drama based on a novel by Caleb Carr, The Alienist. Set in the 1890s, The Alienist follows a newly appointed police commissioner, a criminal psychiatrist, a newspaper illustrator, a strong-willed secretary, and twin detective sergeants as they come together to investigate the deaths of the male prostitutes in the city.

The team faces opposition from their department by some members keener on protecting the high-class people than bringing justice to the murdered children and stopping the gruesome crimes.

  • Release Date: January 21, 2018
  • Running Time: 1h
  • Cast: Luke Evans, Brian Geraghty, Robert Ray Wisdom, Douglas Smith, Matthew Shear
  • IMDb Rating: 7.7/10
  • Where to Watch: HBO Max, TNT, Netflix, Prime Video.

7# Capitani (2019-2020)

20 Thrilling Shows Like The Sinner | Come And Solve These Murders Mysteries!  

Capitani (2019) is Luxembourg’s first Netflix series. It is a crime drama series that follows Inspector Luc Capitani as he investigates the murder of 15-year-old Jenney Engel. He is assisted by the local police officer Elsa Ley.

Throughout the investigation, the duo realizes that the townspeople know more than they admit. So, the investigators don’t only have to track down the murdered but also penetrate further into the complex mentality of the townspeople who are being manipulated for the “common good.”

  • Release Date: February 11, 2019
  • Running Time: 24-32 minutes
  • Cast: Luc Schiltz, Sophie Mousel, Claude de Demo, Joe Dennenwald.
  • IMDb Rating: 6.5/10
  • Where to Watch: Netflix

8# Homecoming (2018-2020)

20 Thrilling Shows Like The Sinner | Come And Solve These Murders Mysteries!  

Homecoming (2018) is an American Psychological thriller series. It is based on a podcast by Gimlet Media, Homecoming. The show revolves around Heidi Bergman, a social worker at the Homecoming Transitional Support Center, run by the Geist Group, a secret government facility. The live-in facility helps soldiers adjust and transition into civilian life.

Four years after Heidi starts working as a waitress, she realizes that she has difficulty remembering her time at Homecoming. Later she finds out she was misled about the unconventional facility’s true aim.

  • Release Date: November 2, 2018
  • Running Time: 24-37 minutes
  • Cast: Julia Roberts, Bobby Cannavale, Stephen James, Shea Whigham, Alex Karpovsky
  • IMDb Rating: 7.4/10
  • Where to Watch: Prime Video

9# Alias Grace (2017)

20 Thrilling Shows Like The Sinner | Come And Solve These Murders Mysteries!  

Alias Grace (2017) is a Canadian drama television series based on a 1996 novel by Margaret Atwood, Alias Grace. Set in 19th century Canada; it revolves around a psychiatrist, Dr. Simon Jordan, who interviews Grace Marks, a celebrated murderess, and decides if she should be released due to her mental state.

Grace used to be a hired house help who was allegedly involved in the double homicide of another house help and their master. However, she doesn’t remember any of this because of bouts of amnesia.

  • Release Date: September 25, 2017
  • Running Time: 4h 27m
  • Cast: Sarah Gadon, Edward Holcroft, Rebecca Liddiard, Zachary Levi, Kerr Logan.
  • IMDb Rating: 7.7/10
  • Where to Watch: Netflix

10# The Night Of (2016)

20 Thrilling Shows Like The Sinner | Come And Solve These Murders Mysteries!  

The Night Of (2016) is an American crime drama television series based on a 2008 series by Peter Moffat, Criminal Justice. The Night Of follows a young man Nasir Khan who, after a long night of s*x and drugs with a woman, Andrea, finds her dead in the room. He leaves the scene immediately but is later caught for minor traffic violations.

Nasir is found with a knife, an incriminating piece of evidence that ties him to the crime scene. Plus, several witnesses are testifying against him. Nasir is put behind bars, but a defense lawyer, Mr. Stone, decides to take up his case.

  • Release Date: July 10, 2016
  • Running Time: 56-96 minutes
  • Cast: John Turturro, Riz Ahmed, Bill Camp, Payman Maadi, Afton Williamson
  • IMDb Rating: 8.5/10
  • Where to Watch: Prime Video, Hulu, HBO

Shows Like The Sinner On Netflix | Solve These Murder Mysteries Now! 

Here are some more shows like The Sinner on Netflix that you would love to binge-watch. But, speaking from my personal experience, I’d advise you to take a break after solving each case! 

Show’s NameDirectorIMDb RatingRunning Time (per episode)
American RustDan Futterman7.2/101h
Mare of EasttownBrad Ingelsby8.5/101h
The WoodsLeszek Dawid, Bartosz Konopka6.6/105h 6m
Mr. MercedesDavid E. Kelley7.8/101h
HightownRebecca Perry Cutter6.6/101h
The FallAllan Cubitt8.1/101h
QuicksandLisa Farzaneh7.5/1045m
EyewitnessAdi Hasak7.5/1042m 
Top of the LakeJane Campion7.4/101h
Perry Mason Erle Stanley Gardner7.6/1056–64m
Sacred Games Anurag Kashyap, Neeraj Ghaywan8.5/1043–58 m
The Equaliser Antoine Fuqua 5.4/10 43–44 m
Luther Jamie Payne 8.4/10 1h
Sharp Objects Jean-Marc Valle 8.1/10 55–61 m
Giri/ Haji Ben Chessell, Julian Farino7.8/1056–60 m
Twin Peaks Mark Frost, David Lynch8.8/10 45m
Elite Carlos Montero, Darío Madrona7.3/10 41–59 m
Narcos: Mexico Andi Baiz8.4/10 45–69 m

Final Words

Now that I’ve befriended you with several murder mysteries floating around, it is in your hands to track down the killer before any more innocent lives are lost. Will you be able to do it?! Watch these shows, The Sinner, and save a life, one at a time, and let your inner detective awaken! 

Jasleen Kour
Jasleen Kour
If you want options for anything worldwide, she'll give you all the best options available using her creativity. Similarly, she has many similar options for your favorite movies and series. She knows what her readers want and always delivers the same. Jasleen is a graceful member of our team, who does everything with elegance!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here